Skip to main content

If you want to know how important SATs are, ask a Year 7 teacher.

This week is the first 'SATs week' since I left teaching. Although I am no longer part of the process, I have been thinking about it a lot over the last few days, and it would be remiss of me not to write a post summarising my feelings.

I have seen lots of examples on social media from compassionate and creative teachers explaining how they have gone above and beyond to make the week as pleasant as possible for their children, as we did. I applaud them, of course, but instead of feeling inspired by their commitment to their children, it just makes me sad.

Yes, school should be challenging, and we should have high expectations, but it cannot be right that we expose the children to something so unpleasant that we have to counteract it by spending our own money on them just to 'get through' the experience.

Some argue that we are preparing the children for the next stage in their education by teaching them how to 'do' exams in the relatively friendly environment of primary school, but I don't buy it. Children aged 10 and 11 are not emotionally ready for the pressure of this kind of experience, and when you look at the emotional age of our children in 2025, many are significantly below this. Don't get me started on exemptions to the exams - have you seen how poor a student needs to be to qualify for this? What about children who work more methodically than others and might not finish the test? Is it right that they are 'punished' for something that we would praise in a normal class situation.

Obviously, the biggest argument for SATs is that they measure the progress children have made over the last six years. But do they really do that? No, of course not. What they actually measure is how good children are at taking an exam, which often has little to do with their actual ability. They also measure how well the school prepares children for their exams, so they cannot realistically be used to compare the quality of teaching in schools. Of course, the knock-on effect of all this is that SATS prep takes over year six early on in the academic year, reducing the amount of learning that takes place in their final year in primary school and reducing year six teachers to the role of exam facilitators.

The impact of SATs is also felt post exams, as the children completely switch off from their learning, so the summer term is a write off too.

If we have to do something, then we all teach to the national curriculum so why not just ensure that teacher assessments are standardised? There, easy wasn't it?

I can honestly say that I hugely regret not being one of those headteachers who boycotted SATs during my time as a school leader. I think I felt that it would be meaningless in the bigger picture, but I should have followed my heart.


Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Things I have learned since leaving the classroom.

I know in my first post I set out a grand plan for what I am going to write about, but I want to slip this one in first. Here are some things I have learned since leaving the classroom. Parents are right when they complain about school traffic. It is as bad as they say it is. I have found that there are times of day that it is wise to stay off the roads if you live within, or want to get to somewhere within a mile of a school. Its not just primary schools, as I have been caught out visiting a supermarket close to a secondary school at home time. It seems that the children (sorry, young people) are too cool to have mum (or dad!) pick them up at the school gate but not too cool that they mind being collected from the Sainsbury's car park next door. The flip side of this is that, if you time it just right, the supermarkets are almost completely deserted if you can find one that is not too close to a secondary school and get there at about 2:55pm. Mums (or dads!) will be otherwise enga...
Post a Comment
Read more

I was proud to be the head of a 'woke' school.

I really don't understand people who use 'woke' as an insult. As far as I can tell, it means being thoughtful, empathetic and inclusive, which doesn't sound like an insult to me. When I was a headteacher, my school was very much a 'woke' organisation, and I am proud to say that this was as much due to the attitudes of the children as to the example set by the staff. We had pupils who identified as being transgender, families with same-sex parents, families from many different cultures, and our children quite rightly accepted everyone as being part of our school community. Perhaps the thing that made me the most proud, though, was the fact that when I became the headteacher there we still heard children using the word 'gay' as an insult, but by the time I left my school, that had disappeared entirely. Knowing quite a bit about our families, I suspect that 'wokeness' was largely driven by our children making their own decisions about how they wante...
Post a Comment
Read more

Wellbeing Wednesday

I would like to begin by clarifying that the title of this post is intended to be somewhat ironic. I have noticed the term 'Wellbeing Wednesday' used frequently in schools, and I must point out that this approach is flawed. Wellbeing should not be confined to a single day each week; for it to be truly effective, it must be integrated into daily routines on Monday, Tuesday, Thursday, and Friday as well, and perhaps even more crucially, over the weekend! Each Wednesday I am planning to publish a post themed on one of my own recommended wellbeing strategies. They will be strategies that you can use to support the children, to support staff, or to support yourself. They will be achievable, realistic and hopefully fun too! The theme for this week is 'Pick a Team'. I was considering calling it 'join a team' but I appreciate that many of us don't have the time or the inclination to physically do that. If you do then good luck to you and I am sure it will have a pos...
Post a Comment
Read more